Blog HCP Consul on Azure goes GA, plus more Consul news from HashiConf EU Read more
  • Overview
    • Consul on Kubernetes
    • Control access with Consul API Gateway
    • Discover Services with Consul
    • Enforce Zero Trust Networking with Consul
    • Load Balancing with Consul
    • Manage Traffic with Consul
    • Multi-Platform Service Mesh with Consul
    • Network Infrastructure Automation with Consul
    • Observability with Consul
  • Enterprise
  • Tutorials
  • Docs
  • API
  • CLI
  • Community
GitHub
Download
Try HCP Consul
    • v1.12.x (latest)
    • v1.11.x
    • v1.10.x
    • v1.9.x
    • v1.8.x
    • Overview
      • Overview
      • What is a Service Mesh?
      • Overview
      • Chef, Puppet, etc.
      • Nagios
      • SkyDNS
      • SmartStack
      • Serf
      • Eureka
      • Istio
      • Envoy and Other Proxies
      • Custom Solutions
    • Overview
    • Manual Bootstrap
    • Consul Agent
    • Glossary
    • Required Ports
    • Bootstrapping a Datacenter
    • Cloud Auto-join
    • Server Performance
    • Kubernetes
  • API
  • Commands (CLI)
    • Register Services - Service Definitions
    • Find Services - DNS Interface
    • Monitor Services - Check Definitions
    • Overview
    • How Service Mesh Works
    • Configuration
      • Overview
      • Ingress Gateway
      • Mesh
      • Exported Services
      • Proxy Defaults
      • Service Defaults
      • Service Intentions
      • Service Resolver
      • Service Router
      • Service Splitter
      • Terminating Gateway
      • Overview
      • Envoy
      • Built-in Proxy
      • Proxy Integration
      • Managed (Deprecated)
      • Overview
      • Proxy Service Registration
      • Sidecar Service Registration
    • Service-to-service permissions - Intentions
    • Service-to-service permissions - Intentions (Legacy Mode)
    • Transparent Proxy
      • Overview
      • UI Visualization
      • Overview
      • Discovery Chain
    • Connectivity Tasks
    • Distributed Tracing
      • Overview
        • WAN Federation
        • Enabling Service-to-service Traffic Across Datacenters
        • Enabling Service-to-service Traffic Across Admin Partitions
      • Ingress Gateways
      • Terminating Gateways
      • What is Cluster Peering
      • Create and Manage Peering Connections
      • Cluster Peering on Kubernetes
    • Nomad
    • Kubernetes
      • Overview
      • Go Integration
      • Overview
      • Built-In CA
      • Vault
      • ACM Private CA
    • Develop and Debug
    • Security
    • Overview
    • Installation
    • Technical Specifications
    • Common Errors
    • Upgrades
    • Overview
    • Architecture
      • Installing Consul on Kubernetes
      • Installing Consul K8s CLI
        • Minikube
        • Kind
        • AKS (Azure)
        • EKS (AWS)
        • GKE (Google Cloud)
        • Red Hat OpenShift
        • Self Hosted Kubernetes
        • Consul Clients Outside Kubernetes
        • Consul Servers Outside Kubernetes
        • Single Consul Datacenter in Multiple Kubernetes Clusters
        • Consul Enterprise
        • Overview
        • Federation Between Kubernetes Clusters
        • Federation Between VMs and Kubernetes
        • Overview
        • Systems Integration
          • Overview
          • Bootstrap Token
          • Enterprise License
          • Gossip Encryption Key
          • Partition Token
          • Replication Token
          • Server TLS
          • Service Mesh Certificates
          • Snapshot Agent Config
          • Webhook Certificates
        • WAN Federation
      • Overview
      • Transparent Proxy
      • Ingress Gateways
      • Terminating Gateways
      • Ingress Controllers
      • Configuring a Connect CA Provider
      • Health Checks
        • Metrics
    • Service Sync
      • Overview
      • Upgrade An Existing Cluster to CRDs
    • Annotations and Labels
    • Consul DNS
      • Upgrading Consul on Kubernetes
      • Upgrading Consul K8s CLI
      • Uninstall
      • Certificate Rotation
      • Gossip Encryption Key Rotation
      • Configure TLS on an Existing Cluster
      • Common Error Messages
      • FAQ
    • Compatibility Matrix
    • Helm Chart Configuration
    • Consul K8s CLI Reference
    • Overview
    • Requirements
    • Task Resource Usage
      • Installation
      • Secure Configuration
      • Migrate Existing Tasks
      • Installation
      • Secure Configuration
      • ACL Controller
    • Architecture
    • Consul Enterprise
    • Configuration Reference
    • Overview
    • Register Lambda Functions
    • Invoke Lambda Functions
    • Overview
      • Installation
      • Requirements
      • Configure
      • Run Consul-Terraform-Sync
    • Architecture
      • Overview
      • Status
      • Tasks
      • Health
      • Overview
      • task
      • start
    • Configuration
    • Tasks
    • Terraform Modules
      • Overview
      • License
      • Terraform Cloud Driver
      • Overview
      • Terraform
      • Terraform Cloud
    • Compatibility
    • Consul KV
    • Sessions
    • Watches
    • Overview
      • General
      • CLI Reference
      • Configuration Reference
    • Configuration Entries
    • Telemetry
    • Sentinel
    • RPC
    • Overview
      • ACL System Overview
      • Tokens
      • Policies
      • Roles
      • Rules Reference
      • Legacy Mode
      • Token Migration
      • ACLs in Federated Datacenters
        • Overview
        • Kubernetes
        • JWT
        • OIDC
        • AWS IAM
    • Encryption
      • Overview
      • Core
      • Network Infrastructure Automation
    • Overview
    • Admin Partitions
    • Audit Logging
    • Automated Backups
    • Automated Upgrades
    • Enhanced Read Scalability
    • Single sign-on - OIDC
    • Redundancy Zones
    • Advanced Federation
    • Network Segments
    • Namespaces
    • NIA with TFE
    • Sentinel
      • Overview
      • FAQ
    • Overview
    • Improving Consul Resilience
    • Anti-Entropy
    • Consensus Protocol
    • Gossip Protocol
    • Jepsen Testing
    • Network Coordinates
    • Consul Integration Program
    • NIA Integration Program
    • Vault Integration
    • Proxy Integration
  • Consul Tools
    • Overview
    • Compatibility Promise
    • Specific Version Details
      • Overview
      • General Process
      • Upgrading to 1.2.4
      • Upgrading to 1.6.9
      • Upgrading to 1.8.13
      • Upgrading to 1.10.0
    • Common Error Messages
    • FAQ
    • Overview
      • v1.11.x
      • v1.10.x
      • v1.9.x
      • v0.3.x
      • v0.2.x
      • v0.1.x
      • v0.4.x
      • v0.3.x
      • v0.2.x
      • v0.6.x
      • v0.5.x
    • Overview
    • ACL
  • Guides
Type '/' to Search

»Consul vs. SkyDNS

SkyDNS is a tool designed to provide service discovery. It uses multiple central servers that are strongly-consistent and fault-tolerant. Nodes register services using an HTTP API, and queries can be made over HTTP or DNS to perform discovery.

Consul is very similar but provides a superset of features. Consul also relies on multiple central servers to provide strong consistency and fault tolerance. Nodes can use an HTTP API or use an agent to register services, and queries are made over HTTP or DNS.

However, the systems differ in many ways. Consul provides a much richer health checking framework with support for arbitrary checks and a highly scalable failure detection scheme. SkyDNS relies on naive heartbeating and TTLs, an approach which has known scalability issues. Additionally, the heartbeat only provides a limited liveness check versus the rich health checks that Consul performs.

Multiple datacenters can be supported by using "regions" in SkyDNS; however, the data is managed and queried from a single cluster. If servers are split between datacenters, the replication protocol will suffer from very long commit times. If all the SkyDNS servers are in a central datacenter, then connectivity issues can cause entire datacenters to lose availability. Additionally, even without a connectivity issue, query performance will suffer as requests must always be performed in a remote datacenter.

Consul supports multiple datacenters out of the box, and it purposely scopes the managed data to be per-datacenter. This means each datacenter runs an independent cluster of servers. Requests are forwarded to remote datacenters if necessary; requests for services within a datacenter never go over the WAN, and connectivity issues between datacenters do not affect availability within a datacenter. Additionally, the unavailability of one datacenter does not affect the discovery of services in any other datacenter.

github logoEdit this page
IntroGuidesDocsCommunityPrivacySecurityBrandConsent Manager