» Consul vs. Envoy and Other Proxies
Modern service proxies provide high-level service routing, authentication, telemetry, and more for microservice and cloud environments. Envoy is a popular and feature rich proxy.
Proxies require a rich set of configuration to operate since backend addresses, frontend listeners, routes, filters, telemetry shipping, and more must all be configured. Further, a modern infrastructure contains many proxies, often one proxy per service as proxies are deployed in a "sidecar" model next to a service. Therefore, a primary challenge of proxies is the configuration sprawl and orchestration.
Proxies form what is referred to as the "data plane": the pathway which data travels for network connections. Above this is the "control plane" which provides the rules and configuration for the data plane. Proxies typically integrate with outside solutions to provide the control plane. For example, Envoy integrates with Consul to dynamically populate service backend addresses.
Consul is a control plane solution. The service catalog serves as a registry for services and their addresses and can be used to route traffic for proxies. The Connect feature of Consul provides the TLS certificates and service access graph, but still requires a proxy to exist in the data path. As a control plane, Consul integrates with many data plane solutions including Envoy, HAProxy, Nginx, and more.
Consul provides a built-in proxy written in Go. This trades performance for ease of use: by being built-in to Consul, users of Consul can get started with solutions such as Connect without needing to install other software. But the built-in proxy isn't meant to compete on features or performance with dedicated proxy solutions such as Envoy. Consul enables third party proxies to integrate with Connect and provide the data plane with Consul operating as the control plane.
The Connect feature of Consul operates at layer 4 by authorizing a TLS connection to succeed or fail. Proxies provide excellent solutions to layer 7 concerns such as path-based routing, tracing and telemetry, and more. Consul encourages using any proxy that provides the featureset required by the user.
Further, by supporting a pluggable data plane model, the right proxy can be deployed as needed. For non-performance critical applications, the built-in proxy can be used. For performance critical applications, Envoy can be used. For some applications that may require hardware, a hardware load balancer such an F5 appliance may be deployed. Consul provides an API for all of these solutions to be integrated.